YIELDS: 12 | PREPARATION: 90 minutes | COOKING: 18 minutes | SKILL LEVEL: Intermediate | Recipe by Kirsten Tibballs
Let’s be honest—these aren’t just cookie cups, they’re dangerously addictive little pockets of joy.
As seen demonstrated live by Kirsten on stage at the 2025 Sydney Good Food & Wine Show, these golden peanut cookie cups are filled to the brim with a rich, silky chocolate caramel that oozes indulgence in every bite.
The contrast of the crumbly, nutty shell with the glossy, melt-in-your-mouth centre is enough to make you weak at the knees. They're salty, sweet, smooth, crunchy—and completely irresistible.
Consider this your official warning: one is never enough, and sharing is absolutely optional.
PEANUT COOKIE CUPS
vegetable oil spray, for greasing
85 g
unsalted butter
65 g
brown sugar
65 g
caster sugar
95 g
crunchy peanut butter
30 g
whole egg
125 g
plain flour
pinch
baking powder
pinch
sea salt
75 g
good-quality milk chocolate, chopped
plain flour, for dusting
CHOCOLATE CARAMEL FILLING
250 g
fresh cream 35% fat
1 tsp
vanilla bean paste
pinch
sea salt
185 g
caster sugar
65 g
liquid glucose
35 g
water
150 g
unsalted butter
25 g
honey
½ tsp
bicarbonate soda
75 g
good-quality milk chocolate